Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Julian Estevez's avatar

Nice! I'm reading now the book Numbers don't lie, by Vaclav Smil, and among many things, he defends that still manufacturing things is what makes a country rich. Software doesn't employ so much people, and manufacturing distributes profits better.

Ricardo Santos's avatar

Philipp, thank you once again for presenting us with a very interesting article, particularly for me, who works within the ecosystem of a German automotive group and has been closely following this entire global situation. My interpretation remains the same: the European problem is not a lack of sales, customers, or even technical skills. The problem is that the European economic model has stopped working. Europe absolutely needs to reinvent itself if it wants to try to stay alive in this fight. Another point in the article that caught my attention was the following: "Chinese market leaders like CATL don’t publish margins, but are seen as clearly profitable." It is necessary to pay attention to the fact that Chinese numbers are not always as transparent as European or American ones. And here comes a point that many Western analysts mention: the Chinese state can distort reality. However, what convinces me most that the Chinese threat is real is not actually the margins of its companies. It's another piece of data from your article: eight of the ten fastest-growing automotive suppliers are Chinese. Even if the exact margins are debatable, the growth in industrial capacity, exports, investment in technology, and market share gains are a very visible phenomena and difficult to disguise for years. That said, and as much as I distrust the exact margins presented for some Chinese companies, I distrust even more those who think that Chinese industrial growth is just propaganda. The challenge for Europe is real, and we have to know how to adapt and reinvent ourselves. Thank you again, Philipp.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?